More observations from our Crowd Numbers quant team as - in partnership with Norstat - they investigate some of the mid- and post-pandemic themes that are emerging...
We are now six weeks, or 43 days, into the UK’s coronavirus lockdown. Almost a month and a half of living under imposed conditions, causing us to change many things about the way we live. Some of our habits are no longer possible: socialising at the pub, going to the gym, commuting to work. Some of our habits have been compounded: watching TV, eating snack foods, ordering online. And then some of us will have formed new habits: working at home, video calling friends and relatives, cooking with new ingredients, helping others in our community.
In our Covid-19 study with Norstat, we have seen a notable uplift in the way the crisis is affecting spending habits. Between early April and mid-April, the number of people claiming that the crisis will have a long term effect on their spending habits jumped from 46% to 57%. Now into early May, this increased figure is holding. The longer the lockdown lasts, the less likely it is that life will return to an old ‘normal’ and the more likely it is that some of the habits we have picked up during corona will simply be the ‘new normal’.
For brands navigating through this crisis, knowing which habits will stick (because, of course, many will) and which will twist, is a difficult call to make. It’s a topic we’ve started exploring for clients across categories such as alcohol, water, media and home; reaching powerful outcomes that are having an immediate impact across comms, brand and innovation. Check in to find out more.
Crowd DNA New York’s Lizzy Hussey and Eden Lauffer unpack the semiotic codes of control in the newly booming feminine care space...
For decades, the femcare market has remained unchanged. Seen as taboo or ‘dirty’ and laden with stigma, periods have been framed as unpleasant medical inconveniences best kept out of sight. However, a cultural shift instigated by a new wave of feminism – and nourished by startup culture and the Instagram aesthetic – has brought new category disruptors to the fore.
Through a semiotic analysis of 35 sources (primarily US and UK based), we’ve identified the dominant, emergent and future-facing codes that chart femcare’s shifting relationship with control. Crucial to how we understand the category, this lens offers guideposts to navigate femcare evolution.
Dominant code: Control as external expertise
Walking down the ‘feminine hygiene’ aisle of a drug store, blue and purple tones fill the shelves. Take sanitary pad market leader, Always: the indigo and magenta color scheme is reminiscent of hues used by banks, pharmaceutical companies and even royalty, to cue authority, safety and control. This alignment with enforced expertise signals control over periods – they’ve been taken out of our hands.
This message is reinforced by imagery of smiling, carefree young women and girls, suggesting lives free from the ‘mess’ of periods. Rays of sunshine peek into these images, hinting at a protective higher and external power taking control. Language is concise and instructive with taglines like, ‘feel confident and protected for less’ implying a sense of guidance. Clean, standardized, sans serif fonts (synonymous with road signage, prescription labels and instruction manuals) also push this sense of external direction. It’s perhaps, then, no surprise that the emergent code of femcare is all about reclaiming agency and control through self exploration and acceptance.
Emergent code: Control as something to be taken back
Brands like ohne and Yoni feature close up shots of human bodies, cropped to draw attention to their flesh and physicality. Unlike the clothed images used in the dominant code, these intimate visuals signal an exploration, reclamation and acceptance of one’s body. The focus on, and visibility of, the body also indicates that this code is very much rooted in the self.
Liberal use of symbolic representations of vaginas (both visual and verbal) is another way these brands signal body intimacy and ownership. Fruits, often papayas with their suggestive shape and dark seeds, are a popular choice; as are flowers, calling on metaphor from O’Keeffe’s paintings. Yoni’s namesake is one of these stylized representations of female genitalia. Other language choices alternate between the euphemism-free (simply ‘vagina’) and the more stylized curses, like ‘pussies’ and ‘bullshit.’ These images and words communicate that this is a creative, pleasurable subject, not a clinical one, introducing a degree of permissiveness around the category totally unseen in the dominant code.
However, the vernacular of this code remains largely rooted in symbols – partially objectifying the topic to permit its discussion.
Future-facing code: Control as social change
Moving past authority to acceptance, the future-facing emergent code sees control manifesting as social change and purpose, evidenced by socially conscious cues that demand action.
While visuals of the body still abound in this code, the tonality of brands like Thinx has shifted. Several of the images are of embrace, of people holding each other, opening themselves up to contact. This conveys a message of support and community, standing in contrast to the previous code’s more self-focused narratives. Diverse portrayals of body shapes and skin tones, alongside fluid language choices like ‘human’ over ‘woman’ and ‘girl,’ are signals of inclusivity and bolster this sense of solidarity.
Taking this further, brands like Thinx and Freda who tap into this code also use words like ‘smash,’ ’ ‘rise’ and ‘manifesto,’ employing the language of revolution, power and violence to signal confrontation with hegemonic ideals and an overthrow of existing order.
Understandably, for established brands, this idea of drastically upending existing conventions is probably a little unnerving. But the reality is that culture has the power to transform, and that categories with major players are often subject to disruption through seismic cultural shifts. Femcare is undergoing one of these moments, and the brands that identify and unpack these cultural shifts will be best placed to weather this disruptive storm.
Reach out if you’re interested in learning more about semiotics at Crowd DNA, and how it can help you identify and unpack cultural shifts.
Our Crowd Numbers quant team have partnered with Norstat to start investigating some of the mid- and post-pandemic themes that are emerging...
With the picture changing so quickly, we are a little suspicious of anyone making particularly bold claims for what life post-pandemic will be like. Instead, we’ve focused on more channelled and specific work, focusing on the very real and particular challenges our clients are facing across different categories and markets.
But we do think there is now the potential to starting pinpointing and tracking some areas of sentiment. And hence we’ve partnered with Norstat to gather data across the next weeks, using a UK sample.
We will flesh this work out as the weeks go by; revisiting themes that we feel are worth tracking; and also introducing new themes as they become more pertinent.
DON’T GO QUIETLY INTO THE NIGHT
With reports that advertising budgets are being slashed across the board, does this leave consumers in the dark as to where to spend their post crisis cash? 58% of UK consumers agree that brands should continue to advertise throughout lockdown and 34% agree that they are just waiting to get in store and treat themselves to some retail therapy. Now is not the time to go quiet on your customers.
ACTION POINTS: Don’t go quiet on consumers. Be vocal in both marketing and PR. Demonstrate your role in the community and be a destination for consumers when they return to the highstreet.
SAVE OUR STORES?
Consumers are rallying to save their favourite brands from the brink, as both big and small brands start to fall casualty to the crisis. 72% of consumers say they will be sad to see some brands disappear due to Covid-19 and 68% said they would be willing to help local independent shops navigate the crisis.
They are particularly willing to help those supporting the vulnerable, with 60% saying they will continue to align with those brands post-pandemic. But for now, attitudes appear ahead of behaviour, as only 45% agree that they are actively trying to spend more with the independents, and only 33% say they have been exposed to new brands during this spell.
ACTION POINTS: Demonstrate that even global brands can have community value, and promote local produce/products where possible. Consumers are willing to help but need to know how. With marketing down, consumers are missing out on opportunities to help brands in the way they wish.
LIGHT AT THE END
72% agree that Covid-19 will have a lasting effect on British culture, and hopefully a positive one. 41% say they will continue to give up time to help the vulnerable, and 42% said that they will make more time to help out in their community.
And what’s more British than the pub? If British culture does change, the average punter does not want to lose their watering hole. 72% said they feared for the future of their local bars and restaurants. But when we do emerge from our homes, it will be to commute back to the office. Only 31% agree that they will try to work from home more often post-pandemic. And with 69% agreeing Covid-19 will have had a positive effect on the environment, it should be a more pleasant commute at that.
ACTION POINTS: Consumers believe the new normal to be a brighter one, with more community care and more support for the vulnerable. Cafe culture and bars/restaurants may see a bounce back as consumers remember how good socialising can be. Don’t abandon office spaces as your staff want to get back in the office with their colleagues.
Check in with Crowd Numbers director Dave Power to learn more about this work – and about Crowd DNA’s quantitative capabilities more broadly.
* Crowd DNA’s Numbers team collaborated with Norstat on this work, surveying an 18+ nat rep UK sample on April 4.
From ‘skintellectuals’ to K-pop collaborations, our new instalment of Crowd Tracks exposes the changing face of beauty over the past four months...
Download the full copy of Crowd Tracks: Beauty here.
We’re back with round two of Crowd Tracks – a social data dispatch highlighting emerging trends using our Culture At Scale method. This time, the spotlight is on beauty, as we look back at the viral stories and online conversations sprucing up the category.
The last few months have been turbulent (to say the least) and we completed most of this edition before the full extent of the Covid-19 crisis became clear. While the observations still have relevance both now and post-pandemic, we’ve also made some adjustments to reflect the new beauty behaviours that we’re starting to see.
The full report features:
– Viral stories from around the world – from female politicians breaking beauty taboos, to the growing appetite for halal and vegan cosmetics in South East Asia
– A brand leaderboard highlighting the companies that are making the biggest waves in beauty through nostalgic throwbacks and K-pop collaborations
– A spotlight on how UZ deployed a cloak-and-dagger campaign at New York Fashion Week to ignite a cult following
– Deep-dives into active beauty, the industry-wide paradigm shift putting power in the hands of consumers and creating a new generation of DIY dermatologists
– Our view on how Covid-19 is set to accelerate the virtual beauty space as people stay home and get creative with AR filters and lenses
Download the full copy of Crowd Tracks: Beauty here.
Culture At Scale at Crowd DNA
At Crowd DNA, we’re constantly tracking conversations online across a range of categories. We deploy social media and other unstructured data sources in a number of ways; either as a stand-alone method (including producing one-off and periodical reports for our clients) or integrated alongside semiotic, ethnographic and quantitative approaches. If you’d like to find out more about how we can use Culture At Scale to meet your business challenges, get in touch.
In a second week of isolation, the Crowd DNA NYC team have been recording their experiences…
As the world is driven further into isolation, and terms like ‘quarantine’ and ‘social distancing’ become commonplace, you’d be forgiven for thinking that our lives just got a whole lot lonelier. At work, we no longer sit directly next to our colleagues. We no longer meet our friends for coffee, go to the movies together, or exercise in a room full of strangers. As for most brands, the in-store experience is indefinitely on hold. Yet despite our new found physical isolation, we’re finding interesting ways to connect.
At Crowd DNA New York, we wanted to explore how we’re now doing that connecting. Whether it’s shifting social gatherings online, virtually supporting local businesses or simply getting nearer to ourselves, we’re finding new ways to boost our sense of closeness in this physically isolated world.
Crowd DNA New York’s Eden Lauffer and Lizzy Hussey interrogate the semiotic codes that brands are employing amid the Covid-19 crisis, as they reach out to let people know that they are there for them...
If you’re living on planet Earth and have email, chances are you’ve received a few (or tons) of missives informing you how various brands are reacting to Covid-19.
We’ve stretched our semiotic muscles, analyzing email marketing received over the last five days to uncover what these brands have been saying – and more importantly – how.
Readers of our semiotics content hopefully recall that normally we explore a relevant topic through the lens of one brand. But these are not usual times. What’s noteworthy at the moment is that most brands have felt compelled to communicate their response over the same medium. Looking at the different ways they’ve done so lets us unpack how verbal and visual cues affect the ways we culturally understand ‘responsibility’ and ‘care.’
Care as a formal reassurance
As crisis grips, the need for voices of confidence, clarity and unwavering strength become more important than ever.
One company we see leaning into this code is Target. A recent email from their CEO was filled with strong, guiding language like ‘committed,’ ‘determined,’ and ‘purpose.’ Cueing confidence and decisiveness, this language works to ensure Target’s customers feel protected and enables the brand to adopt the position of a responsible and trustworthy leader.
Further underscoring this sense of respect and formality is the email’s left-aligned text, which acts as a visual manifestation of order. And where the brand usually relies on lively, bright red visuals and images of smiling people, this email forewent heavy branding or imagery.
By visually deprioritizing the brand, Target is literally conveying that it takes a backseat to public safety and the national interest. The email closes with the CEO’s signature, a final signal of formality and personal responsibility, and one that indicates how some brands are semiotically behaving more like public institutions than commercial enterprises. This alignment with a national message, as almost a civic call to duty, engages the brand with the people they seek to comfort and bolster.
Care as community support
As we’ve retreated indoors, concern for small and local businesses has spurred social posts urging us, as neighbors, to get creative in our support. We’ve also seen brands such as Uber Eats adopt this code of community into their outreach.
Speaking with collective nouns like ‘our’ and ‘we,’ and choosing to write from their entire team (vs. an individual CEO) establishes a peer-to-peer tonality that emphasizes community, and positions Uber Eats as part of it.
This is supported by language choices like the header: ‘We’re in this together. Let’s support local restaurants,’ and the deliberately local-first tone, which highlights small business owners and workers, delivery personnel, and first responders in need. The subtle use of green throughout the note bolsters cues for growth and community renewal.
Though this is expressed differently, in aligning themselves with the community, Uber Eats is another example of a brand behaving like an institution rather than a commercial offering.
Care as a brief respite
While the previous two codes of care confront Covid-19 head-on, a few brands have taken a different approach.
Local fast-casual chain, Dig Inn, for instance, does not explicitly refer to Covid-19 once in its communication. Instead, its language – with the opening line ‘A lot of things are changing, but your lunch doesn’t have to be one of them’ – offers both support, but also respite from the constant flow of coverage; it reassures readers that some elements of normalcy and their routine can remain.
While the font is simple and the message concise, even the use of Dig Inn’s typically bold and bright images of their natural and vibrant food permits a sense of respite, cueing the pleasure and sensory stimulation that is lacking in more formal brand comms (eg Target, Uber Eats).
How to care
We all care. And demonstrating that care as a value is more important than ever right now. It’s admirable and vital that brands are ready and willing to take up their social roles and help the planet manage and recover from its current plight.
It’s also very important, as a brand, to be able to express a sense of responsibility and offer reassurance in a way that is both culturally relevant and effective. What this post underlines is that there are many ways to express this care, each with differing implications for how it positions you in the cultural landscape.
At Crowd DNA, we’re learning fast about how to work under current conditions. We’re adjusting our methods and already working on Covid-19-related briefs for clients in areas such as alcohol, media, retail, home and luxury. Check in with us if you’d like to find out more.
Is America ready to make fun of itself? Crowd DNA New York’s Eden Lauffer explores how this year’s Super Bowl ads are poking fun amid the turmoil...
With the Trump presidency in the US and Brexit anxiety in the UK, both locales are no stranger to turmoil. But as fires spread in Australia and China’s coronavirus lockdown continues, 2020 seems to have kicked off with a feeling of worldwide unrest. In the first few weeks of January alone, online memes have been crying World War III and the end of humanity as we know it (with a humorous twist, of course). It’s no surprise, then, that escapism has become a fully-fledged trend since the 2016 US election. Consumers retreat from the noise of politics into rent-a-nap centers, drag culture, astrology charts etc.
Escapism takes a new form in this year’s Super Bowl ads. After all we’ve been through in just the first month of 2020 – the Harvey Weinstein trial, the impeachment case, the overwhelming number of presidential candidates – America is ready to start making fun of itself. And while funny, over the top ads are synonymous with the Super Bowl, this year, their tone is a different kind of escapist humor – it’s more tongue in cheek.
Of those ads, we’ve identified three cultural trends that they fall into, namely: mocking millennials, poking fun at devices that listen to us, and lightly treading on political satire.
Mocking Millennials, Again
If you’re a millennial (as I am), you may find millennial jokes tiring by now. But in this year’s ads, the media seems to be on our side with several brands playing on some of the typical ways people like to mock this generation. For example, millennials are often criticized for spending on unnecessary items such as avocados. In response, Avocados From Mexico stages a shopping network featuring absurd products for your avocado to use, such as a pool floaty or a bike helmet.
Another popular millennial jab revolves around a lax work ethic. In a similar vein, we see Cheetos and MC Hammer join forces to help one millennial escape his responsibilities using the excuse of ‘Cheeto fingers’. As millennials now make up a prominent percentage of our population, these blows nod to a somewhat thicker-skinned America.
The idea that our devices are constantly listening is not a new one. As we continue to rely on technology and give up personal information, privacy becomes a more glaring concern. Even with this anxiety we continue using apps that may be leveraging our faces to strengthen facial recognition. A number of this year’s Super Bowl ads poke fun at our comfort with privacy invading devices. In Pringles’ and Bud Light Seltzer’s ads, Morty (of Rick & Morty) and Post Malone fall captive to mind control, respectively.
The commentary in the Pringles ad presents an extreme scenario of brands consuming our minds, encouraging us to buy new products. In the Bug Light spot, Post Malone’s brain is manned by a control center dictating which actions he should make when purchasing a drink. We complain about devices taking over, but still feed the problem. So at this point, perhaps it is best to just laugh at the continuing spiral of how much we rely on them.
Tip-Toeing On Political
In post-2016 election Super Bowls, some brands took a political stance, alluding to their position on the Trump Administration actions like building a wall. However, this year’s ads transcend any political stance by instead mocking the general political climate in the US, including how non-Americans perceive the country’s unrest. In a jovial song, Americans band together to #FixtheWorld by feeding it a giant Snickers. The ad features babies named Kale, moms sending nudes, and influencers falling into an enormous hole. Budweiser approaches this same satire in a more subtle way, playing on negative American stereotypes. The narrative dismisses a ‘typical American’ for being loud, while the ad shows a group of protestors speaking out on a cause. While the 2016 election showed an America more divided than expected, there’s still common ground between us. The ability to laugh about the ridiculousness of things like babies named Kale bands together people on both sides.
In early 2017, many Americans wanted nothing more than to escape the turbulence of the United States. Advertising shied away from our new president and everything that came along with him. It helped us forget our troubles by transporting us to simpler times. Think, for example, of the silly humor of Bud Light’s ‘Dilly Dilly’ campaign. Today, as we’re in the depths of a trial aimed at impeaching the president, it feels as if the pressure has reached boiling point. These ads prove that we’re beginning to laugh at ourselves again; and as we prepare for another presidential term, this satirical American voice helps cut the tension.
Marking the Lunar New Year this weekend, we’re releasing our full report on the major shifts shaping culture in China. Download Inside China to find out what TikTok has to do with Maoism, and how coffee cups can signal a low-key youth revolution...
China represents one of the most exciting opportunities for international brands – but also one of the hardest markets to crack. With a whiplash-inducing rate of change, keeping up to speed is a pretty big task.
Perceptions of China are often either outdated or contradictory. Is it capitalist or communist? Cutting edge or catching up? In our 2019 Rise event of the same name (repeated by popular demand!), we took a tour along the fault lines of these tensions to reach five key cultural shifts.
As the rate of progress burns through the baggage of societal rules and restrictions, Chinese youth are balancing individualism with an inherited tradition of collective toeing the line. In this report, we go into the products of this tension. There’s the wave of national pride putting a fresh spin on the label ‘Made In China’; the new currency of status that goes beyond the material; and the leap from consumption to high-volume creative output.
For brands looking to make an impact in this market, swotting up is key. Our Inside China report takes you through our five indentified cultural shifts, as well as a crash course in how brands can make the switch from playing catch-up to leading the way. Download it here.